Ironyca Stood in the Fire

A WoW blog about Minecraft

Summing it Up – Gender-bending pt. 10

The Gender-bending series is based on the result of my own little survey, attempting to map all the motivations of WoW-players playing a character of the opposite gender. Each part deals with a certain aspect of gender-bending in games. This is the summary post, pt. 10.

Prelude

Part 1: Advertizing the survey
Part 2: Throwing myself to the lions….I mean trolls!

Results

Part 3: The Spectacle of Play and Characters
Part 4: Avoiding Clones
Part 5: To Wear or to Not Wear Robes
Part 6: Bring the Player, not the Gender
Part 7: Uniqueness and the Trademark of the Female Dwarf
Part 8: In Game Advantages
Part 9: For the Love of Names

Conclusion

Part 10: Summing it Up

Gender-bending in WoW has to be understood as part of the medium of games. To the outsider (which sometimes includes players than don’t gender-bend) it might look weird and as if someone has issues with their gender identity. I bring you an example of this from someone who posted in my survey-advertizement thread, saying they did not play characters of the opposite  gender because:

No, im confident of my sexuality :P

I wrote in part 3, that this is nearly never part of the issue, and gender-benders know this.  As virtual worlds provide a space where players can inhabit separate bodies they create themselves, although under the restriction of character creation modes, they can play and experiment with the character’s appearance. To people who play a character of the opposite gender, the option of male or female is often viewed alongside other choices such as class and race. Playing WoW includes playing with avatars, which gender-bending can be viewed as a product of.

In addition, when we look at WoW as a part of a gaming history, we understand that players come with a heritage as well. Some of them have been using the game medium for years and are used to creating characters in many different genres, including ones which only allows for certain genders to be the main character, or a certain class. Gender-bending in WoW, despite the fact the reason to gender-bend to unlock new mechanics is nigh, is neither unusual nor deviant, but generally a common phenomenon amongst players.

Overall gender-bending works as a tool of either specified gain or avoidance, with the wish to achieve a form of variety, playing the biggest part. The many available modes of play in WoW, the different classes which opens for new mechanics and therefore new ways of playing the game, alleviates being able to make this range of characters look different and apart important to players. Aesthetics were central to the majority of players as well, although specific reasons were far and apart. The wish for smooth and aesthetically pleasing modeling and animations were fundamental, but also cultural understandings of gender in trying to abide by them or avoiding them, were present.

Using WoW as a place to explore gender is less common, but nonetheless favored by female players, who play male characters in order to avoid attention and perhaps to blend in to the male dominated space in WoW. Gaining benefits in the game as a motivation for gender-bending ranged overall low.

Being able to stand out and create a unique character was exhibited, but still in accordance with a high aesthetic value to the players. The name of a character is perhaps the highest form of individuality one can achieve in WoW, and thus a particular name were more befitting of the opposite gender for some players.

I believe gender-bending can tell us a lot about both the ways characters in the game are perceived and utilized by players, but also how cultures and norms of the game and its players, can both co-exist but also challenge each other.

One of the initial reasons this interested me, was the difference in occurence between the genders, female gender-benders were very rare and I wanted to know why. As my survey didn’t include people that didn’t gender-bend, I don’t have the other side of the coin. One of my sources, Ducheneaut, Wen, Yee and Wadley’s (2009) study Body and Mind: A Study of Avatar Personalization in Three Virtual Worlds, could indicate the reason behind this, so this will have to be my best guess: Female players prefer creating idealized versions of themselves more than male players (especially in Second Life) and I believe gender is linked to  projecting a version of identity, whether it’s congruent or wishful, onto a character.

One of the posters said on the general forum when I posted the survey:

[...] I don’t understand why people take the gender of a virtual character seriously…

Another poster, and a very insightful one of the kind I’d say, responded saying this:

Gender studies is an extremely fascinating field. Gender is a very complicated construct. It’s taken for granted by the vast majority of people, after all, because it’s the norm to accept  the one you’re assigned to at birth, and most are comfortable with that. To others, it’s an endless source of confusion and frustration, because it’s a cornerstone of one’s identity and forcing something like that is very unsettling, to say the least.

Of course, as you say, it’s not quite the same for a virtual character. But the way we are adressed and treated is still defined by which gender we are perceived as. To those who struggle with these things, it’s very important and not something you can just shrug off. (link)

Think about it, the internet, the virtual worlds where we can choose our own bodies, can challenge how most people look at gender and identity. In WoW or any other virtual world (or chat rooms/forums etc for that matter) you can be whatever you want and some games even include the option to be neuter. The fact  the physical presence and gender of people are dislocated when we meet them in virtual worlds, I think, can change how we understand identity, approach others and construct ourselves. In what circumstances in WoW does it really matter what gender you are?

As our lives are increasingly dependent and influenced by computer technology, games that inhabit this medium become a more stable part of our leisure activities. While the subscription number of WoW continues to rise alongside other similar platforms, so does the spreading of how we utilize virtual bodies – avatars/characters to the mainstream, perhaps rendering this mode of being and play completely normal in the future.

About these ads

10 comments on “Summing it Up – Gender-bending pt. 10

  1. ChopStickSoSushi
    July 26, 2011

    While I don’t Acctualy play WOW I have played as a Female Neko in final fantasy 11 online through my Xbox360, why I did that is simple if I am going to stare at the backside of an avatar for hours and hours on end I would rather look at a beutiful rendering of a woman then the chunky ugly body of the male avatars… from what I see MMORPGs do not give males a very pleasing figure to choose from. & more detail tends to be given to the female avatars clothing and movements to make them flewid (Playstation Home) then are given to the males.

    But I do play as my male gender in Playstation Home… thanks for allowing the cross platform gaming comment as I do feel it is applicable to this study.

    • ironyca
      July 26, 2011

      Thanks for commenting, you’re right, it’s not just a WoW thing, but something you will find in any game even if you go back in time. I’ve heard the reasoning about a more complete and better put-together model before, it would be interesting if the designers actually did spend more time polishing them, who knows :)

  2. Anonymous
    April 10, 2012

    I’m obviously late here, but just to put it in, I play mostly female characters and I am male. My main is a male, and I’ve never created a female dwarf, or any vanilla Horde race female. I personally believe that while some races look better as females, still some look better male.

    • ironyca
      April 10, 2012

      Even though you say you’re late, I suspect this topic is one that will float around only to resurface once in a while for some time still, so thank you for your comment!

  3. Madison
    April 17, 2012

    Almost all of my characters in WoW are male, and I’m a female. As you said in the post, I do it to blend in with the male dominated space. It’s very annoying, when everybody and their brother flirts with you. I’m just trying to play a game and have fun!

    • ironyca
      May 18, 2012

      You are according to the statistics very rare! Thanks for your comment :)

  4. Dan
    May 2, 2012

    Speaking from the other side of the coin, the theories above seem half right the other half being people who shield there true gender, identity from people get stuck into an elusive loop. Iv played a fair few mmorpg and this effect isn’t unique to Wow or type some fps have a similar occurence.

    Nice site

  5. Genevieve
    September 24, 2012

    Boy am I late commenting. I’m a female who plays a mix of female and male toons, with a majority being male. (In WoW amongst other games) Aesthetics is what is is to me. Also, a lot of armor is really skimpy on the female models where it isn’t on men… which is frustrating, because I want to be a serious female warrior; not one with exposed vital organs running around with her boobs bouncing in the way.

    Also, I quite like the male models. Though a lot are silly :P
    Male worgen are probably my favourite. They’re huge and threatening, and I love that. If I’m gonna be a werewolf, I’m gonna be one that can crush your head with his hand.

    I don’t mind if people mistake my gender (almost everyone believes girls don’t play WoW anyway) but the lack of sexism from males is definitely a perk to playing a male toon. x3

    There are a lot of reasons, and I fear I am rambling now. It’s an interesting study… but maybe I’m a bit fluid with my gender. (Mostly, I really just don’t give a damn ;3)
    But thanks for taking interest in it. ;3

    • Ironyca
      September 24, 2012

      Hey, thanks for commenting!
      I’ve started playing my first male character a year ago, almost as a bit of an experiment to see how I liked it. Sometimes I feel as if I am able to pass as male when I play him, as if people just assume. He’s a gnome, and contrary to you, I think I lean towards the smaller and skimpier male races. Don’t know what that says about me really :D

What's your opinion?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Instagram

Roskilde LEGO Mindstorms. I'll be playing with this thing tomorrow! My walk home

Archives

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 71 other followers

%d bloggers like this: